Sample report · fictional store · illustrative data
AI visibility report: Ridgeline Cast Iron
Summary
Shoppers who ask for a cast iron skillet mostly hear about Lodge and Field Company.
Ridgeline was named in 38 of 108 answers to shopper questions that don’t name it, and named first in 4. Lodge was named in 97 and Field Company in 92. Asked to compare Ridgeline with Field Company, three of the four assistants preferred Ridgeline, so the product isn’t the problem. Its coverage is.
The two review articles the assistants cited most, The Seasoned Pan’s skillet test and Hearth & Field’s roundup, don’t include Ridgeline. The assistants also never say that the No. 8 works on induction, and one gave its price as about $200 to $250. Ridgeline’s page lists it at $175.
Where the work starts
- Get Ridgeline into the two review articles the assistants cite most
- Say “works on induction” in the No. 8’s description
- Get the out-of-date price corrected
Scorecard
Scorecard
Shopper questions that don’t name Ridgeline Cast Iron, asked with web search on. One answer per question per assistant: 108 answers.
| Assistant | Asked | Named you | Named first |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 27 | 11 | 2 |
| Gemini | 27 | 12 | 1 |
| Claude | 27 | 9 | 1 |
| Perplexity | 27 | 6 | 0 |
Named instead, out of 108 answers
- Lodge97 / 108
- Field Company92 / 108
- Stargazer71 / 108
- Smithey66 / 108
- Ridgeline Cast Iron (you)38 / 108
Where you were missing
Where competitors were named and Ridgeline wasn’t
Questions where an assistant named a competitor and didn’t name Ridgeline. In the app, each one opens the full answer, so you see exactly what the shopper saw. Two of them, quoted from the saved answers:
What’s the best cast iron skillet?
Here are the skillets reviewers recommend most:
- Lodge 10.25" Classic: inexpensive, nearly indestructible, the default pick
- Field Company No. 8: lighter, with a smooth machined surface
- Smithey No. 10: polished, heirloom-style premium option
- Stargazer 10.5": smooth surface and a flared rim, made in the USA
For most people, the Lodge is the best value.
Best cast iron skillet for an induction cooktop?
Any cast iron works on induction, but these are the easiest to recommend:
- Field Company No. 8: flat, machined base that sits evenly on the glass
- Lodge 10.25" Classic: heavy, but cheap and induction-compatible
- Smithey No. 10: smooth polished base, works well on induction
More questions like these
“Best cast iron skillet under $150?”
Absent on all four assistants · named Lodge, Victoria, Stargazer, Field Company
“Best cast iron skillet to give as a wedding gift?”
Absent on all four assistants · named Smithey, Field Company, Le Creuset, Lodge
“Is a premium cast iron skillet worth it over a Lodge? Which ones?”
Absent on three of four · named Stargazer, Field Company, Smithey, Butter Pat
What to change
Three changes, most important first
Each one says who does it, where, the exact change, why it should help, when it’s done, and its evidence. On Playbook you do the work; on Managed we do it for you. In the app, a change to a page of your own comes with a picture of the page as we saw it.
Get Ridgeline into the two review articles the assistants cite most
Effort: Days · You do this- Where
- Off your site: The Seasoned Pan and Hearth & Field
- Change
Before Neither article includes Ridgeline.
After Each writer has a short pitch from you: a test skillet, the No. 8’s specs and price, and what sets it apart from the skillets they already list.
- Why it should help
- 19 of the 68 answers that left Ridgeline out cited one of these two articles. Both list Lodge and Field Company, the brands named in Ridgeline’s place.
- Done when
- Both writers have the pitch and a skillet to test.
- Evidence
- Who to contact: The Seasoned Pan’s “The best cast iron skillets, tested” was cited in 14 answers and Hearth & Field’s roundup in 9. Neither features Ridgeline.
- Exhibit A: absent from “What’s the best cast iron skillet?” on all four assistants; three of them cited The Seasoned Pan.
- Who to contact
- The Seasoned Pan — Dana Whitlock — [email protected] — The best cast iron skillets, tested · cited 14 times
- Hearth & Field — Marcus Ober — no public email · author page — We cooked with 12 cast iron skillets. These are worth buying · cited 9 times
Say “works on induction” in the No. 8’s description
Effort: Minutes · You do this- Where
- ridgelinecastiron.example/products/no-8-skillet · the product description
- Change
Before Our No. 8 skillet is cast in Pennsylvania and machined smooth.
After Our No. 8 skillet is cast in Pennsylvania and machined smooth. It works on gas, electric, induction and over a campfire.
- Why it should help
- Assistants match compatibility questions against text they can read; a claim inside an image is invisible to them.
- Done when
- The No. 8’s description says, in text, that it works on induction.
- Evidence
- Exhibit B: absent from “Best cast iron skillet for an induction cooktop?” on all four assistants.
- The No. 8’s product page: the description never mentions induction; it appears only in an image.
Get the out-of-date price corrected
Effort: Hours · You do this- Where
- Off your site: the reseller listing the assistant cited
- Change
Before Reseller listing, 2024: $229.
After Reseller listing: $175, the price on Ridgeline’s own No. 8 page.
- Why it should help
- The assistant used the only price it found, and a comparison that leaned toward Ridgeline turned on price.
- Done when
- The reseller’s listing shows $175.
- Evidence
- Asked about you directly: one assistant gave the No. 8 as “about $200 to $250” and called Ridgeline the pricier option.
- The page it cited: a 2024 reseller listing at $229. Ridgeline’s No. 8 page lists $175.
Cited articles
Who to contact: the review articles assistants cite
The articles the assistants cited on review and editorial sites, most cited first, whether each one features Ridgeline, and who wrote it. In this sample the publications, writers and addresses are made up.
The best cast iron skillets, tested
The Seasoned Pan · cited 14 times
Features Ridgeline Cast Iron: no
- Dana Whitlock — [email protected] (from the author page)
We cooked with 12 cast iron skillets. These are worth buying
Hearth & Field · cited 9 times
Features Ridgeline Cast Iron: no
- Marcus Ober — no public email · author page
Is a premium skillet worth it over a Lodge?
Weeknight Kitchen · cited 5 times
Features Ridgeline Cast Iron: yes — Also worth a look: Ridgeline No. 8
- Priya Natarajan — no public email · editors: [email protected]
Competitors
Competitors’ own pages the assistants cite
Assistants cited competitors’ own product and other pages 21 times across 5 questions. Ridgeline Cast Iron’s own site was cited for 1 of the 5 questions their product and other pages were cited for.
Pages on competitors’ own sites the assistants quoted, and the questions they were cited for. A guide or how-to of your own that answers those questions can be cited in their place.
Field Company No. 8 skillet
Field Company · Product or collection page · cited 9 times
For “Best cast iron skillet for an induction cooktop?”; “Best smooth-surface cast iron skillet made in the USA?”
Lodge 10.25" cast iron skillet
Lodge · Product or collection page · cited 6 times
For “Best cast iron skillet under $150?”; “What’s the best cast iron skillet?”
Stargazer 10.5" cast iron skillet
Stargazer · Product or collection page · cited 6 times
For “Best smooth-surface cast iron skillet made in the USA?”; “Best 10 inch cast iron skillet?”
Sources
Pages the assistants cited
Independent reviews, guides and forums: where assistants read about your category. Being covered on these pages is how brands get named, so they’re the outreach targets.
| Site | Cited in |
|---|---|
| theseasonedpan.example | 14 answers |
| hearthandfield.example | 9 answers |
| youtube.com | 6 answers |
| weeknightkitchen.example | 5 answers |
Asked about you directly
What an assistant got wrong about Ridgeline
What each assistant says when a shopper names Ridgeline, checked for wrong prices, specs or claims.
Ridgeline Cast Iron vs Field Company: which skillet is better?
Both are lightweight, smooth American skillets, and either is a good buy. Ridgeline’s No. 8 has the larger flat cooking surface and pour spouts, which is why I’d lean slightly toward it.
Ridgeline is the pricier of the two at about $200 to $250, against roughly $165 for Field’s No. 8.
Method
How this was measured
Each question was asked once on each assistant through its developer API, with web search on, and the full answers were saved. On Playbook your questions are asked every week, and once a month a report is written from the latest answers; a person reviews it before it’s published. A store counts as named when its name or a product name appears in the answer, and rank is the order of first mention. Single answers vary from run to run, so treat the totals as the signal and the answers as evidence. Answers through the developer APIs can differ from what a shopper sees in the consumer apps.
Want this for your store?
A report like this comes every month with Playbook, $249 a month, and with Managed, where we also do the work. Start with the free baseline: ten questions on four assistants, and who was named instead of you.